Fall 2009
| Name | Ht. | Wt. | Year | Hometown |
| Andrew Abbott | 5-7 | 140 | Freshman | Denham Springs, La. |
| Drew Beaty | 6-0 | 150 | Sophomore | Fort Wayne, Ind. |
| Taylor Bontrager | 5-5 | 130 | Freshman | Goshen, Ind. |
| Ryan Daugherty | 5-11 | 145 | Freshman | Indianapolis, Ind. |
| Bill Digman | 5-10 | 150 | Sophomore | Muncie, Ind. |
| Matt Dougherty | 5-11 | 160 | Sophomore | Breese, Ill. |
| Emby Duncan | 5-10 | 155 | Sophomore | Albany, Ind. |
| Taylor Holmes | 5-10 | 135 | Freshman | Monticello, Ind. |
| Eric Linn | 5-9 | 160 | Freshman | Macy, Ind. |
| Dan Malloy | 5-11 | 150 | Senior | Bellefontaine, Ohio |
| Kirk Saunders | 5-10 | 125 | Freshman | Bloomington, Ill. |
| Kyle Schmidt | 5-8 | 135 | Senior | Ossian, Ind. |
| Marc St. Amour | 5-8 | 150 | Sophomore | Schererville, Ind. |
| Matt St. Amour | 5-10 | 170 | Sophomore | Schererville, Ind. |
| Jeff Vibbert | 5-9 | 125 | Freshman | Fishers, Ind. |
| Jake Wyatt | 5-11 | 130 | Sophomore | Hudson, Ind. |
